Rick Repetti
\nKingsborough Community College
\nCity University of New York <\/p>\n
This is my reply to Karin Meyers, \u201cFalse Friends: Dependent Origination and the Perils of Analogy in Cross-Cultural Philosophy,\u201d in this Symposium. Meyers generally focuses on exegesis of what Early Buddhists said<\/em>, which reasonably constrains what we may think about them if we are Buddhists. I agree with and find much value in most of her astute analyses, here and elsewhere, so I restrict my reply here to where we disagree, or otherwise seem to be speaking past, or misunderstanding, each other. In this regard, I focus on three of her claims. Meyers argues that (1) Buddhist dependent origination is not determinism; (2) attempts at naturalizing Buddhism threaten to run afoul of her hermeneutics; and (3) I seem to err on both fronts. However, I have emphasized that I am not a determinist, and I am not as concerned with what Buddhists did say about causation and agency. As a philosopher, I am mainly concerned with what philosophers can say about them. Thus, Meyers\u2019s criticisms of my work seem predicated on interpretations of ideas I do not exactly espouse. Thus, the \u201cRepetti\u201d that Meyers primarily critiqued, as the title to this Reply (hopefully humorously) makes clear, wasn\u2019t me! Whether I have failed to make my ideas clear, she has failed to accurately interpret them, or some combination of both, I am uncertain. Thus, I focus on trying to clarify those ideas of mine that Meyers seems to interpret in a way that I do not. ISSN 1076-9005 Volume 25, 2018 It Wasn\u2019t Me: Reply to Karin Meyers Rick Repetti Kingsborough Community College City University of New York This is my reply to Karin Meyers, \u201cFalse Friends: Dependent Origination and the Perils of Analogy in Cross-Cultural Philosophy,\u201d in this Symposium. Meyers generally focuses on exegesis of what Early Buddhists said, which … Continue reading It Wasn\u2019t Me: Reply to Karin Meyers<\/span>
\nRead article<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"