Month: November 2025 (Page 6 of 6)

The Travels of Ibn Battutah: Malli

As Ibn Battutah nears the end of his journey, he travels throughout Sub-Saharan Africa to what he refers to generally as “the Country of the Blacks.” In particular, he speaks at great length about the city of Malli. In Malli, Ibn Battutah becomes far less concerned with musing over beautiful architecture and religious spaces. It’s possible that this is simply due to a lack of this, or at least a lack of impression made on Ibn Battutah. More likely, I think, is that there was such extensive cultural and biological difference that Ibn Battutah observed that he was simply too shocked by these other differences to note architecture. His main concern, like it is in many other places, is hospitality.

He first reflects on how they provided for him and make them welcome, which he praises, but then he becomes quite ill upon eating a cultural dish – so ill that a friend of his dies – and this is where his perception of their hospitality begins to change. The next section is filled with hatred about how they treat visitors. Here, however, he shows a mixed reaction. While we can infer his view partially changes because he thinks himself poisoned, he does seem to feel much thanks to the men for concocting him a purgative that rids him of his sickness. This scene is a great reflection of our class discussion centering around how Battutah thinks of race and how his perceptions are related to aid and care. When he arrives in Malli, he receives the customary welcome gifts. Being on the receiving end of presents and care to make them comfortable, Battutah praises them beyond their race. Similarly, he still speaks well of them when they heal him during his sickness. However, resentment for the poisoning and a new realization that the gifts presented aren’t “good enough” change Battutah’s mind. 

One care that he maintains from earlier sections is that of rulers and sultans. After he heals, he visits the Sultan of Malli, who he immediately begins to say terrible things about, citing him as “miserly” and says his gifts are not sufficient (286). The only thing more he mentions is that they share the same religion, before going on to complain more about the gifts. Battutah expects that his gift will be lavish – robes, money, etc – but is appalled to find that it is no more than a meager amount of bread and beef. He then begins to dig into the character of the people of Malli, calling out his surprise at “their feeble intelligence and exaggerated opinion of something contemptible” (287). Here, we see quite clearly that he thinks his own cultural practices of welcome gifts to be far superior, and that he and his peers find non-monetary gifts to be insulting, though we gleam through the gift and the serving of the favorite cultural food earlier that, in Malli, those gifts are of the highest regard. He goes as far as to accost the sultan into giving him something better.

We learn the most about the beliefs and customs of Battutah’s own country when we are given a detailed account about what was good and what was bad “in the conduct of the Blacks” (289). It is interesting to notice that the things he praises are majoritively religious in nature, while the things he despises are majoritively cultural. For example, he praises the Blacks “avoidance of injustice” and the ways in which the Sultan “doesn’t allow anyone to practice it in any measure” (289-90). He seems to go as far as learning a new practice he finds fascinatingly positive and may be willing to enact himself, and that is the binding of the children until they learn the Qur’an. Religion usurps race and culture in Battutah’s view. Among the “bad” practices are the “comical” recitation of poetry, the nudity of women, and the food they consume, such as dogs and donkeys. This, Battutah finds abominable. Between this and the meal he fell ill from, we can see that he cares greatly about food practices and finds those in Mali animalistic and inferior. 

Ibn Fadlan: The Land of the Bāshghirds

From pages 23 to 25 Ibn Fadlan passes through a Turkish territory, and the people he meets he calls the Bāshghirds. The caravan had to cross many rivers before entering the land of the Bāshghirds. Interestingly none of the names of the rivers appear on the map, “The Journey of Ibn Fadlān, 921-922” (suggesting the names may have changed). Ibn Fadlan and his fellow travelers had to journey on these rivers on “folding boats made of camel skin” (22). He was impressed by the Jāyikh river which he says is “the most impressive and the swiftest” river he has seen (23). Additionally, the river they crossed to get to the land of the Bāshghirds was the Kunjulū. To leave the land of the Bāshghirds they also had to cross a river called the Jirimshān (and then many others). This is an interesting aspect, because there were very few concrete political borders at this time. The rivers, somewhat, outline the lands of different groups. This suggest that there was a reliance on natural borders at the time to define where people lived. When Ibn Fadlan is among the Bāshghirds he focuses on their religious and spiritual practices/customs. He observes that they keep wooden phalluses with them and some of them believe in twelve lords who oversee different aspects of the earth. Ibn Fadlan also observes religious differences amongst the Bāshghirds. He states, “We saw a clan that worships snakes and another that worships fish and another that worships cranes” (24). Beyond religion, Ibn Fadlan describes these people as “dirty” (23). He claims they eat lice and fleas after he witnesses one man do so.

                  In this section there is an emphasis on cultural divisions. Ibn Fadlan’s tone does not come off as judgmental or dismissive when he discusses their religious practices. It is indifferent and just sounds like he is recording what he sees. The part where his tone changes is in relation to their cleanliness and eating bugs. He calls them the “dirtiest” along with the “worst” which emphasizes his relationship to cleanliness. Ibn Fadlan’s deep connection to his faith and his job (Islamic Jurist) likely influence his perceptions. He is indifferent to their religious practices because the Bāshghirds are not Islamic, however, Ibn would take cleaning rituals very seriously. Therefore, he may associate moral value with dirtiness or cleanliness.

                  Additionally, Ibn Fadlan’s connection to his job and faith further influences his perceptions based on geography. Ibn Fadlan does not stay in the Bāsghird’s territory for very long based on his writings. A majority of what he witnesses (despite the instance with the man supposedly eating a flea) is their religion to which he is indifferent. Yet, he immediately makes assumptions about their qualities. He calls the Bāshghirds “the worst of the Turks” (23). This group of people also happen to be in the most northern part of Turkish territory (right before entering another territory-Bulghar). His perceptions of people are progressively becoming more negative as he advances north; which he would like associate with Hell and the tribes of Gog and Magog. Therefore, despite his short stay with these people, he considers them poorly and dislikes them immediately.

 

Ibn Fadlān. Ibn Fadlān and the Land of Darkness: Arab Travelers in the Far North.Translated by Paul Lunde, Penguin Classic, 2012.

The Travels of Sir John Mandeville: Medieval Map

The fact of the matter is that it does not even make sense to put the travels of Mandeville on any map that even tangentially holds to reality. Any map that even pretends to depict Earth shows that he either loved traveling in the worst possible way to get anywhere or that he was simply not real. Spoiler alert, he was not real. This becomes the most obvious when you see how he ping pongs across the Mediterranean. When you read the travels, it makes sense that he goes from where St. Nicholas was born to where he was elected bishop. That makes perfect sense, right? Nope! Not even a little bit. The monk who was sitting alone in his tower, thinking about St. Nick, must have thought that St. Nick travelled a couple of miles outside of his hometown and got set up as a bishop. But he did not do that at all! He crossed half the bloody Mediterranean to get elected bishop.  So this monk, or whoever wrote the travels, we’re not quite sure who wrote them, but given the content, of the centrality of the trip to Jerusalem, the focus on religious figures as he moves through the world, his knowledge of the places where religious figures were and his lack of practical information regarding their physicality it is safe to say that he was a monk. Let us just call him Tim, for convenience. (We can dismiss entirely the idea that Sir John Mandeville was a real person. He rarely, if ever, talks about how he gets to places, or the people that he talks to there, and the people he does talk to seem more like rhetorical devices than actual people.) So Tim has his OC, John Mandeville, and wants to take him along the paths that important religious figures in the past took, without any regard to geography. Tim wants John to follow these people’s itineraries, where they were and where they were going. What map do we use for that? Even on the most weird and fucked up t-map, even on one that centers Jerusalem, which I agree would seem to be the best in a story that clearly so centrally deals with Jerusalem, the trip from Patras to Myra passing over Kos and Rhodes, which he then goes back to, does not make any sense. If I am going to Cedar Point, in Ohio, with my younger sibling Teddy (a real trip that I’m looking forward to), and we leave from Pittsburgh and decide that we want to stop in Youngstown and Akron, we’re not going to stop in Akron and then double back to Youngstown. That’s going to add an hour to the trip, not to mention the cost of gas, Dr. Pepper, and Doritos that this detour demands. If you told me that you were taking that route, I would assume that you had not taken this trip and put it on a map. I do not need to tell you that the medieval costs of travel were astronomically higher than some petrol and snacks. This trip would get you killed if you had not planned properly. If Mandeville were real, this kind of stupidity would have gotten him killed long before he would have had the chance to write any of this down. Mandeville is so bogus that it does not make sense to use any map other than an itinerary map. Tim was not thinking in terms of geography but in terms of connections and temporality. Need more proof? John goes from Chios, passes Ephesus, to Patmos, then doubles back to Ephesus! Why does he do this? Because it follows the temporality of the life of John the Baptist. John the Baptist wrote The Apocalypse in Patmos and was then buried in Ephesus. Tim just likes to have John move through the word along with the lives of the Saints. It makes for an interesting narrative technique. It also makes it so that there is no real way for us to properly map John’s travels, except for the itinerary map. We could discuss the virtues of the other kinds of maps until we’re blue in the face, but the only way that we can look at the travels of John Mandeville on a map without dismissing it immediately as the merest glint of moonshine is by looking at it through the lens of an itinerary map. I end this blog post feeling as if I have spent my entire post belaboring a single point, but I feel as if it is an important one, and indeed, the only one that I can make. He was not real; he’s a narrative device. Everything that he does is for the sake of the narrative.

The bad way to get to Cedar Point https://maps.app.goo.gl/vBeUT6u2J5Mxkg9G9

https://www.canva.com/design/DAG3tET4e64/_6Snk3xgHFOzYt46ZtGRMQ/edit?utm_content=DAG3tET4e64&utm_campaign=designshare&utm_medium=link2&utm_source=sharebutton

https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1uJCNSU-tfz4Smqy_qcJnyzDgTNMH_Cw&usp=sharing

Medieval (Re)interpretation of the Holy Places: Virtual Pilgrimage, Matthew Paris’s Itinerary Map, and Meditative Tools – The Pilgrim’s Guide

Newer posts »

© 2026 Mapping the Global Middle Ages


Academic Technology services: GIS | Media Center | Language Exchange

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑