Mussolini: His Own Worst Enemy

Mussolini could talk the talk, but could he walk the walk? Simply put, no, he couldn’t. Mussolini’s Fascist diplomacy regarding his foreign and military policies exposed his true character and his illusions towards Italy’s true power and the relationship he maintained with Hitler. Pride remained Mussolini’s Achilles heel. Repeatedly, he ignored the word of his economic and political advisers to save the face of Fascism in the prewar period. Obsessed with prestige, Mussolini invaded and colonized Ethiopia to glorify Italy in the international community and perhaps gain the respect from Hitler and other European powers he thought Italy deserved. After Italy’s humiliating defeat in 1896 during their military conquest of Ethiopia, Mussolini visualized redemption. At huge economic losses, Italy occupied Ethiopia against British and French desire and damaged her relationship with the future allied powers. After defying the British and French, Mussolini decided to gain political favor from Hitler. Mussolini thought if he created an alliance with Hitler, the British and French would become frightened of Italy. This proved to be a mistake, however.

Mussolini “overestimated Italy’s bargaining position; and underestimated Hitler.” (Clark, 280) 1936 marked the signing of the Rome-Berlin Axis and Italian involvement in Spain during the Spanish Civil War alongside Hitler. This failed in two ways: to genuinely increases the strength in alliance between Hitler and Mussolini, while simultaneously destroying any chance of reconciliation with the French and British. The reason it became apparent that this military act did not protect Italy from Nazi invasion was illuminated when Hitler annexed Austria in 1938, which was an obvious territorial threat. Mussolini pressed forward on the same path despite these warning signs, eventually playing himself into Hitler’s hands. In what Clark describes as a “foolish move,” Mussolini sealed his alliance with Nazi Germany with his Pact of Steel in 1939. (Clark, 283) This eventually served to draw Italy into a war that remained highly unpopular with Italian citizens.

Had Mussolini been more patient and less prideful, could Italy have avoided involvement in World War II?

3 thoughts on “Mussolini: His Own Worst Enemy

  1. I think its difficult to ask these “what if” questions, because we’ll never know what could have happened. Had Mussolini not joined up with Hitler, would they have been invaded and forced to engage in the war? If Mussolini wasn’t so prideful and bombastic with his claims of Italian glory, would another leader have stepped up and done the same or something different? We’ll never know. In terms of Mussolini’s innate characteristics such as his apparent lack of patience and extreme pride, I think that war could have been avoided had he not possessed these traits. While the downfall of Italy cannot be attributed solely to Mussolini, he did have a lot of influence. Though he had advisers, he rarely listened to them and even dismissed some. He took on a wide array of titles and responsibilities, and his strategies demonstrated a lack of experience and consideration for long term effects. That all being said, I think it was very difficult to not be involved in the war, whether that means fighting, selling arms or other resources, or trying to resolve for peace (in your favor of course). The fascist state glorified war, so I feel that involvement in some sense would have happened, just not maybe in the way that actually occurred.

  2. I agree with Claire, it is hard to ask these hypothetical questions. However, I do think Mussolini had a prideful, exuberant personality. These personality traits carried with him throughout all of his work, regardless of the situation.

  3. I agree with both Claire and Kristin. Claire addressed many points that I wanted to bring up as I read Jackson’s post. I think another important point to think about is inevitability. Was Italy’s participation in WWII inevitable? Let alone, was the war itself inevitable? Yet again, as mentioned by Claire, it is very difficult to make inferences because we can’t possibly predict what could’ve happen. However, I generally agree that because of the glorification of the Fascist state, involvement in the war to some degree would have happened regardless of Mussolini being more patient and less prideful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *