Cell Senescence and Inflammation: A Link to Atherosclerosis

Summary of:

Ito, T. K., Yokoyama, M., Yoshida, Y., Nojima, A., Kassai, H., Oishi, K., & … Minamino, T. (2014). A crucial role for CDC42 in senescence-associated inflammation and atherosclerosis. Plos One, 9(7). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0102186

 

Trevor Griesman and Alissa Meister

Atherosclerosis is a chronic inflammatory disease affecting medium-large arteries beginning at birth, with the progression depending on many factors. The main risk factors for atherosclerosis include hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes mellitus and others such as age, sex, smoking, and sedentary lifestyle. Possible complications from atherosclerosis include coronary artery disease, cerebrovascular diseases, and peripheral artery disease. Although these complications are responsible for over half of the yearly world mortality, they often occur late in the progression of the disease with limited early diagnoses.

The first molecular event in atherosclerosis is endothelial dysfunction in the arteries as a result of injury or inflammation. This dysfunction takes the form of either cell senescence, apoptosis, or activation. This paper focuses on senescence, when cells stop replicating. Atheroscletotic plaques result from an accumulation of lipids and smooth muscle cell proliferation. In response, endothelial cells over-express adhesion molecules and increase the recruitment of inflammatory cells. These  inflammatory cells further release cytokines, causing a cytokine-mediated progression of atherosclerosis and LDL oxidation.  Plaques deteriorate the cell wall and cause thickening of the surrounding muscles. Accumulation of these plaques can limit the flow of oxygen and nutrients to the rest of the body, leading to serious consequences depending on where these plaques form. Plaques forming in the coronary arteries cause Coronary Artery Disease (CAD), limiting the blood flow to the heart and increasing the risk for blood clots. Similar diseases can develop if these plaques form in the periphery, carotid artery, etc. Symptoms of atherosclerosis also depend on where these plaques form, and may include chest pain, weakness, numbness in the periphery, headache, kidney disease, and many more.

CDC42 is a GTPase in the Rho family responsible for cell cycle regulation functions such as migration, endocytosis, morphology, and cell-cycle progression. Additionally, CDC42 regulates the organization and proliferation of the actin cytoskeleton. Previous studies have shown that CDC42 may act in the senescence and inflammation of cells. The CDC42 pathway has been implicated as a potential therapeutic target for inflammation reduction in aging individuals, however this has yet to be studied in an in vivo model. Ito et al. (2014) set out to study the link between CDC42 and inflammation in senescent cells, and connect this to a potential role of CDC42 in atherosclerosis. The researchers specifically investigated the relationship between CDC42 and the inflammatory NF-κB pathway.

 

EXPERIMENTAL METHODS

In order to create a model for senescence, the researchers cloned the genes for p16 and p21 (cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors) into retroviral vectors, and infected cells. This resulted in the integration of the gene DNA into the DNA of the cells. In order to determine the effects of different CDC42 pathway components, they knocked down genes using siRNA. They then used RT-qPCR (as we did in class) to measure the mRNA levels of three genes: the cytokine CCL2, the endothelial-leukocyte molecule E-selectin (SELE), and Vascular Cell Adhesion Molecule 1 (VCAM1). Western blotting was used to quantify translated levels of these proteins. For some experiments, other proteins, such as a deactivated form of CDC42 were upregulated in cells by infection with an adenoviral vector which contained the DNA that coded for those proteins. To measure innate immune response levels, induced-senescent cells transfected with various siRNAs were treated with LPS or TNF-α, and levels of CCL2, SELE, and VCAM1 mRNA were measured by RT-qPCR.

The researchers also studied mouse and roundworm models. Mice were made into conditional knockouts using a Cre-Lox system, in which special sequences called lox sequences are inserted into the genome flanking the target gene. The protein Cre cuts at the lox regions. A Cre protein was used that is inactive until treated with a drug, in this case tamoxifen. When the researchers introduced tamoxifen into their Cre-Lox mice, they effectively knocked out the gene between the lox sequences. The researchers targeted either CDC42, Mdm2 (a negative regulator of p53), or some combination of those genes. They also used Apolipoprotein E knockout mice. In these mice, they investigated protein expression in tissue sections using immunostaining. They recorded mRNA levels using RT-qPCR, and measured atherosclerotic lesion areas using tissue section staining. Finally, the researchers studied C. elegans worms, specifically the nol-6 strain, which has high innate immune expression due to a p53 dependant pathway. The researchers measured levels of immunity-gene mRNA using RT-qPCR in siRNA treated worms, and tracked the survival of the worms over time.

 

KEY RESULTS

The researchers found that in senescence-induced cells, the NF-κB pathway upregulates pro-inflammatory gene expression (Figure 1). This was shown through the creation of senescent like cells by introducing pathway kinase inhibitors, which led to an increase in inflammatory cytokine and adhesion molecule expression. Furthermore siRNA directly targeting this pathway decreased the inflammatory cytokines. The researchers additionally found that CDC42 also regulates pro-inflammatory gene expression, by testing knockdowns of the CDC42 pathway and observing a decrease in inflammatory molecules (Figure 2). After these two findings surrounding NF-κB and CDC42, the researchers further found that CDC42 up-regulates pro-inflammatory cytokines by activating NF-κB. However, when cells were activated by either LPS or TNF-α, CDC42 knockdowns had had cytokine levels higher than NF-κB knockdowns, implying that NF-κB is downstream of CDC42, as it functions with other methods of activation (Figure 3).

The researchers then decided to test these finding using in vivo models, including several strains of mice and C. elegans. An increase in pro-senescence signalling in atherosclerotic plaques was found, linking atherosclerosis and inflammation (Figure 4). Additionally, CDC42 deletion was found to reduce aortic infiltration by macrophages in atherosclerosis. Overall, using these in vivo models, the researchers found that CDC42 is a mediator of chronic inflammation, which leads to endothelial senescence.

 

BROADER CONTEXT

In senescent cells, replication is halted as cells age to prevent the onset of cancer or other genetic malfunctions. Senescent cells secrete inflammatory cytokines, possibly as a way of signalling to immune cells that will destroy the senescent cell before it becomes cancerous. As we discussed in class, one of the ways that endothelial cells can respond to stress is to become senescent. This can lead to the formation of plaques, as lipids and then immune cells infiltrate the tunica intima. The researchers investigated CDC42 because of its involvement in inflammation following senescence. In the context of plaque formation, if the senescent endothelial cells did not secrete inflammatory cytokines, less immune cells would invade the plaque, slowing the progression of the plaque and possibly preventing the formation of a fibrous cap. However, clinical treatments knocking out CDC42 are very far off, as the inhibition of all senescent inflammatory signalling could result in the buildup of senescent cells, and there is no way to target CDC42 specific siRNA to plaque sites. Additionally, the experiments were done in cell models of senescence, but other factors may contribute to senescence in vivo. 

 

 

References

Mitrovska, S. (2009). Atherosclerosis : Understanding Pathogenesis and Challenge forTreatment. New York: Nova Biomedical Books.

What Is Atherosclerosis? (2014, August 4). Retrieved March 6, 2015, from http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/health-topics/topics/atherosclerosis

 

124 thoughts on “Cell Senescence and Inflammation: A Link to Atherosclerosis”

  1. In the discussion, the authors point out that it is interesting that deletions of CDC42 signaling had a markedly weaker influence on acute inflammation than on chronic inflammation. In fact, all of their evidence demonstrates the importance of the CDC42 pathway in regulating CHRONIC inflammation induced by cellular aging signals. My question: Why isn’t acute inflammation equally influenced by inhibition of CDC42 signaling?

  2. You touched on this in the blog post, but I wanted to discuss further the clinical application of this study. It seems to me that a cell cycle-regulating protein as CDC42 would have many roles in diverse types of cells. It would be difficult, as you mentioned, to specifically target this one role of the molecule. Clearly they have expanded the body of knowledge about the mechanism of disease, but is there much hope for a potential novel therapy to arise out of this research?

  3. Towards the end of the discussion section, the authors mention that CDC42 does not necessarily mediate NF-κB and that their in vivo experiments had slightly different results than the in vitro experiments. They also say that CDC42’s effects could be cell type and context dependent, suggesting that there may be other players involved in this inflammatory response. What other factors could possibly influence this pathway to have similar outcomes?

  4. Midway through this paper and in reference to Figure 2E the authors state that the data suggestsCDC42-induced up-regulation of pro-inflammatory genes was unrelated to cell cycle regulation. Then, towards the end of the paper, they state that their results suggest that CDC42 signaling contributes more specifically to inflammation associated with senescence, defined by the authors as ‘irreversible growth arrest occurring after accumulation of DDR’. To me it is confusing to state that CDC42 signaling is related to senescence but not cell cycle regulation.
    Additionally, early on in the paper the authors state that the pro-inflammatory signals emitted by senescent cells may help to prevent cancer development through the elimination of cells with oncogenes and that this inflammation could also promote tumor progression. I am curious how these processes differ and what allows them to create such different outcomes.

  5. One of the interesting things that I realized while reading through this paper and your post is that many of the pathways, proteins, and drugs used in these experiments are similar to those identified in cancerous processes and treatments. As you discussed, the researchers observed increased inflammation and cytokine levels in their experiments, leading to further understanding of the pathway connecting CDC42 and NF-κB. Based on these findings, I wonder if there is further connection between atherosclerosis treatment and cancer treatments, and how someone with both of these illnesses would be affected through manipulation of CDC42.

  6. You addressed a few of the difficulties with the clinical aspects of CDC42 knockout such as increased senescent cells. But, taking into consideration the large number of genes contributing to inflammation, how can the authors guarantee that through knockout of this particular protein, a desirable therapeutic outcome will result? Also, it does not seem possible to target one specific protein without disrupting other gene expression or cell processes.

  7. One of the interesting i thought of after reading this paper was how a treatment using these findings could be delivered. As with many molecular targets, one concern is off target effects. With the advent of specific gene targeting through systems like TALENs and CRISPR, I wonder if there would be some way to specifically target CDC42 in the plaques formed in the tunica intima. In addition ( as mentioned by other classmates), it would be interesting to see if the complete understanding of the pathway that leads to inflammatory process in atherosclerosis could provide clues to the understanding of other diseases like cancer.

  8. Great comments everyone! As always, we will have too much to discuss on Friday. First, I want to say that I think this paper was very well-written and easy to follow-a good model for writing papers! My second comment is about the data. I think the whole paper was connected very well to senescence, then they jumped to the ApoE model for atherosclerosis in mice and tried to make a senescence connection, which I thought was weak. It was not clear to me that the atherosclerosis induced in ApoE KO mice fed a high fat diet had a senescence component. However, it was clear that cdc42 was playing a role in plaque formation based on Figure 4E (quite a drastic reduction in atherosclerotic plaque area in the ApoE/cdc42 KO mice). To what extent does senescence contribute to atherosclerosis in the ApoE model? The plaque reduction was so great in the ApoE/cdc42 KO mice that I wonder if cdc42 is contributing to atherosclerotic signaling pathways other than senescence-induced pathways.

  9. It was clear how they quantified the data from immunohistochemistry. I really like the part on the paper where it states the reason why they used worms and Apoe KO mice. I am also interested what other elements can be responsible for causing senescence in vivo other than knocking out cdc42 as well. In the meantime, I was wondering how knocking out sym-1 expression can block the inflammation from figure 5? sym-1 is important for p53-dependent activation of innate immunity, but I wasn’t sure blocking sym-1 expression will cause deactivation of all senescence-associated stimuli.

  10. I feel that figure 3 is very important to the study. Though proving that the NF-κB pathway upregulates pro-inflammatory gene expression in senescence-induced cells was key to this paper’s findings, suggesting that NF-κB may be activated downstream of CDC42 may be vital treatment of ALS in the future. Furthermore, by using in vivo and in vitro models, this paper significantly links CDC42 to endothelial senescence.

  11. As we discussed, this article did a nice job explaining the link between CDC42 and inflammation in senescence cell through human, mouse, and worm studies. I would be interested to see if other RhoGTPases, such as RhoA or Rac1 contributed to this inflammatory response as well!

  12. Overall, I understand the purpose of CDC42 with regards to regulation of the inflammatory system. Is CDC42 being one of the predominate factors active in the relevant stress response a good enough reason for the authors to insinuate any future role in treatment of atherosclerosis? This conclusion seems a little off-base as a more efficient treatment would not be preventing growth of the plaque but rather preventing this unnecessary breakdown in the endothelial wall that allows for entrance of foreign bodies in the first place.
    –> The main thing that I want to gain a better understanding of is how much wiggle room is there in GOOD science when making conclusions and connections about the importance of any research findings?

  13. 不需要大量的時間和金錢,僅需30個小時左右的特殊培訓,你就能輕鬆通過你的第一次參加的Huawei H12-711_V4.0 認證考試。PDFExamDumps能為你提供與真實的考試題目有緊密相似性的考試練習題。

  14. Thank you for this article, it truly expanded my horizons. Thanks to the TA-003-P latest exam camp materials, I moved up in my career and got a raise. Now, it’s free for you all. Wishing you promotions ahead!

  15. 아직도NAHP NRCMA 인증시험을 어떻게 패스할지 고민하시고 계십니까? KoreaDumps는 여러분이NAHP NRCMA덤프자료로NAHP NRCMA 인증시험에 응시하여 안전하게 자격증을 취득할 수 있도록 도와드립니다. NAHP NRCMA 시험가이드를 사용해보지 않으실래요? KoreaDumps는 여러분께NAHP NRCMA시험패스의 편리를 드릴 수 있다고 굳게 믿고 있습니다.

  16. Mit der Ankunft der Flut des Informationszeitalters im 21. Jahrhundert müssen die Menschen ihre Kenntnisse verbessern, um sich dem Zeitalter anzupassen. Aber das ist noch nicht genügend. In der IT-Branche ist EMC D-CSF-SC-23 Zertifizierungsprüfung ganz notwendig. Aber diese Prüfung ist ganz schwierig. Sie können auch internationale Anerkennung und Akzeptanz erhalten, eine glänzende Zukunft haben und ein hohes Gehalt beziehen. Fast2test verfügt über die weltweit zuverlässigsten IT-Schulungsmaterialien und mit ihm können Sie Ihre wunderbare Pläne realisieren. We garantieren Ihnen 100%, die Prüfung zu bestehen. Bewerber, die an der EMC D-CSF-SC-23 Zertifizierungsprüfung teilnehmen, warum zögern Sie noch. Schnell, bitte!

  17. This article has helped me look at the problem from different perspectives, and I’ve gained a lot. This PAL-I latest exam collection pdf helped me advance in my career with a promotion and raise. Now, it’s free to all. Wishing you success in your career paths!

  18. Your article has left a significant mark on me, thank you for it. New free GPCS study guide was the catalyst for my career and salary increase—now I’m giving it to you for free!

  19. This article is so encouraging, thanks for sharing it! I’m offering the Exam ESG-Investing preview test that played a key role in my promotion and salary increase. It’s available for free today—good luck with your career journey!

  20. PrüfungGuide ist führend in der neuesten CheckPoint 156-215.81 Zertifizierungsprüfung und Prüfungsvorbereitung. Unsere Ressourcen werden ständig überarbeitet und aktualisiert mit einer engenVerknüpfung. Wenn Sie sich heute auf die CheckPoint 156-215.81 Zertifizierungsprüfung vorbereiten, sollen Sie bald die neueste Schulung beginnen und die nächste Prüfungsfragen bestehen. Weil die Mehrheit unserer Fragen monatlich aktualisiert ist, werden Sie die besten Ressourcen mit marktfrischer Qualität und Zuverlässigkeit bekommen.

  21. 我們的SAP C_C4H46_2408題庫是由專業的IT團隊以最好的技術水準制作而得到的學習資料,其中整合最新的C_C4H46_2408考試問題得到而來,以確保您購買我們的題庫資料是真實有效的,即使是新手也可以快速輕松獲得SAP C_C4H46_2408認證。對于如此有效的考古題,趕快加入購物車吧!付款之后您就可以立即下載所購買的C_C4H46_2408題庫,這將會讓您在您的考試中獲得高分,并順利的通過C_C4H46_2408考試。

  22. Thank you for sharing this article, it’s incredibly motivating! Improve your IT abilities—free CAE latest study questions sheet now available! Good luck!

  23. Your article is truly inspiring, thank you for sharing such brilliance! Get access to the Exam C-S4EWM-2023 score exam that helped me achieve a promotion and pay raise, now free for everyone today. Best wishes in your professional development!

  24. This article is a real treasure, thank you for sharing it with us. This is the Valid ISTQB-CTAL-TA test question test that helped me secure a promotion and raise. It’s free for everyone today—wishing you all the best in your career!

  25. 우리 Itcertkr에서는 여러분을 위하여 정확하고 우수한 서비스를 제공하였습니다. 여러분의 고민도 덜어드릴 수 있습니다. 빨리 성공하고 빨리Microsoft MD-102인증시험을 패스하고 싶으시다면 우리 Itcertkr를 장바구니에 넣으시죠 . Itcertkr는 여러분의 아주 좋은 합습가이드가 될것입니다. Itcertkr로 여러분은 같고 싶은 인증서를 빠른시일내에 얻게될것입니다.

  26. Cisco 700-841認証試験を通るために、いいツールが必要です。Cisco 700-841認証試験について研究の資料がもっとも大部分になって、Jpshikenは早くてCisco 700-841認証試験の資料を集めることができます。弊社の専門家は経験が豊富で、研究した問題集がもっとも真題と近づいて現場試験のうろたえることを避けます。

  27. I’m deeply grateful to NaturePath Herbal Clinic for the remarkable improvement in my Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) condition. Prior to starting their ALS Herbal Treatment program, my health was declining rapidly. After few months on their ALS Herbal treatment program, I’ve seen major progress, I can now walk independently, and my speech has significantly improved. Visit http://www.naturepathherbalclinic.com.

  28. 周りの多くの人は全部SAP C_HRHFC_2411資格認定試験にパースしまして、彼らはどのようにできましたか。今には、あなたにIt-Passportsを教えさせていただけませんか。我々社サイトのSAP C_HRHFC_2411問題庫は最新かつ最完備な勉強資料を有して、あなたに高品質のサービスを提供するのはC_HRHFC_2411資格認定試験の成功にとって唯一の選択です。躊躇わなくて、It-Passportsサイト情報を早く了解して、あなたに試験合格を助かってあげますようにお願いいたします。

  29. This article has given me more inspiration when thinking about issues. Using the Test 312-76 sample, I achieved a promotion and salary raise. It’s now free to everyone. Wishing you all success in your career journey!

  30. Fast2test는 응시자에게 있어서 시간이 정말 소중하다는 것을 잘 알고 있으므로 Microsoft PL-300덤프를 자주 업데이트 하고, 오래 되고 더 이상 사용 하지 않는 문제들은 바로 삭제해버리며 새로운 최신 문제들을 추가 합니다. 이는 응시자가 확실하고도 빠르게Microsoft PL-300덤프를 마스터하고Microsoft PL-300시험을 패스할수 있도록 하는 또 하나의 보장입니다.

  31. What a phenomenal article, I appreciate you sharing it with us! You’ll find the Reliable exam AZ-120 passing score content valuable, and it’s completely free to access.

  32. Thank you for your article, it really captured my attention. This is the New CCAAK study notes exam that played a role in my promotion and pay raise, now shared with you for free today. Best wishes on your career development!

  33. The content speaks for itself, like clicked. Here’s the 220-1102 exam vce test that helped me get promoted and raise my salary. It’s free today—hope it helps you with your career goals!

  34. H12-891_V1.0認定試験を受験したいですか。H12-891_V1.0認証資格を取得したいですか。試験に準備する時間が足りないあなたは、どうやって試験に合格できますか。しようがないわけではないです。短時間の準備でも楽に試験に合格することができるようになりますよ。それでは、どのようにすればそれを達成できますか。実は方法がとても簡単です。すなわちFast2testのH12-891_V1.0問題集を利用して試験の準備をすることです。

  35. Living with Pulmonary Fibrosis (PF) was one of the hardest experiences of my life. The breathlessness, the fatigue, and the fear of the future weighed on me every single day. I had tried so many treatments and medications, but nothing seemed to stop the disease from progressing.Out of both hope and desperation, I came across NaturePath Herbal Clinic. At first, I was skeptical but something about their natural approach and the stories I read gave me the courage to try one more time.I began their herbal treatment program, and within a few weeks, I noticed small changes easier breathing, more energy, and a clearer mind. Over themonths, those improvements became more and more obvious. Today, I can truly say my life has changed. My lungs feel stronger, and my quality of life has returned in ways I didn’t think were possible.This isn’t just a testimony it’s a heartfelt recommendation to anyone struggling with PF or other chronic conditions. Don’t give up hope. I’m so grateful I gave NaturePath Herbal Clinic a chance.
    Visit their website to learn more: www. naturepathherbalclinic .com

  36. Living with Pulmonary Fibrosis (PF) was one of the hardest experiences of my life. The breathlessness, the fatigue, and the fear of the future weighed on me every single day. I had tried so many treatments and medications, but nothing seemed to stop the disease from progressing.Out of both hope and desperation, I came across NaturePath Herbal Clinic. At first, I was skeptical but something about their natural approach and the stories I read gave me the courage to try one more time.I began their herbal treatment program, and within a few weeks, I noticed small changes easier breathing, more energy, and a clearer mind. Over themonths, those improvements became more and more obvious. Today, I can truly say my life has changed. My lungs feel stronger, and my quality of life has returned in ways I didn’t think were possible.This isn’t just a testimony it’s a heartfelt recommendation to anyone struggling with PF or other chronic conditions. Don’t give up hope. I’m so grateful I gave NaturePath Herbal Clinic a chance.
    Visit their website to learn more: www. naturepathherbalclinic .com

    1. Robert, I really appreciate you sharing your experience. It reminded me so much of what my husband went through with Pulmonary Fibrosis. For years, he struggled with shortness of breath and constant fatigue, and nothing seemed to make a real difference.When we discovered NaturePath Herbal Clinic, we weren’t sure what to expect, but giving their herbal program a chance turned out to be one of the best decisions we ever made. Little by little, his breathing became easier, his energy improved, and he started regaining strength we thought he had lost forever.Your story gives even more encouragement, and I can honestly say that NaturePath has also brought real hope and healing into our lives.

  37. I’m really grateful for this article, it’s so inspiring! The C_BCSSS_2502 latest test simulator helped me secure a promotion and raise. Now it’s free to everyone. Wishing you all a bright future in your careers!

  38. Thank you for your article, it was incredibly enlightening. This is the 300-710 valid test dumps demo test that helped me secure my promotion and pay raise, now shared with you at no cost. Hope you succeed in your career!

  39. 私たちJapancertに知られているように、300-610認定は、急速な開発の世界の多くの現代人にとってますます重要になっています。 300-610認定が多くの人にとってそれほど重要なのはなぜですか?認定を取得することは、人々がより良い仕事をしたり、より多くの富を得たり、より高い社会的地位を得るなど、夢を実現するのに役立つからです。多くの人々は、300-610認定を正常に取得するのが困難です。また、試験の合格と認定の取得に問題がある場合は、300-610クイズ準備を使用する時が来たと思います。

  40. KoreaDumps 는 완전히 여러분이 인증시험준비와 안전이 시험패스를 위한 완벽한 덤프제공사이트입니다.우리 KoreaDumps의 덤프들은 응시자에 따라 ,시험 ,시험방법에 따라 제품의 완성도도 다릅니다.그 말은 즉 알 맞춤 자료입니다.여러분은 KoreaDumps의 알맞춤 덤프들로 아주 간단하고 편안하게 패스할 수 있습니다.많은 Microsoft인증관연 응시자들은 모두 우리KoreaDumps가 제공하는 AI-900문제와 답 덤프로 자격증 취득을 했습니다.때문에 우리KoreaDumps또한 업계에서 아주 좋은 이미지를 가지고 잇습니다

  41. This article is incredible, thank you for sharing it with us! This Printable 350-501 PDF helped me get promoted and receive a salary increase. Now, it’s free for everyone. Wishing you success in your career journey!

  42. Es gibt viele Methoden, die Oracle 1z1-076 Zertifizierungsprüfung zu bestehen. Einerseits kann man viel Zeit und Energie auf die Oracle 1z1-076 Zertifizierungsprüfung aufwenden, um die Fachkenntnisse zu konsolidieren. Andererseits kann man mit weniger Zeit und Geld die zielgerichteten Oracle 1z1-076 Prüfungsfragen von ZertSoft benutzen.

  43. I want to extend my sincere gratitude for all the valuable content you provide. Your articles are always well-researched, easy to read, and full of helpful information. Your website has been an invaluable resource for me, and I can’t thank you enough for the effort you put into creating such top-notch content.
    789bet

  44. Thank you for sharing your knowledge through your website’s articles. Your content is always relevant, informative, and well-researched, making it a great resource for learning. I truly appreciate the effort you put into each post, and I’m grateful for the knowledge I gain from your website.
    Lotto123

Leave a Reply to Hank Nash Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *